• Find your car
• Sell or trade in
• Car finance
• Why Carma?

More choice at the budget end, carried over from autumn

The slower sales this autumn have left buyers with more choice this spring. Fewer than half the cheap cars listed in May were gone within a month, against nearly two-thirds the year before. The ones that waited were still on the market when the buyers came back in July, and they’re part of what you’re choosing from now.

More cars in front of the same buyers means more competition for sellers. If you’re comparing three Corollas this weekend instead of one, you’re seeing that extra choice firsthand, and sellers are competing for your attention.

The same used car lists for about $750 less than a year ago

The price has moved your way as well. In September, a car in this price range was listed for 6.9% less than a comparable car a year earlier. This compares like-for-like cars, accounting for factors such as model, age and kilometres, so it reflects a change in the price of the same type of car rather than a shift in what’s for sale. On a typical $11,000 car, that’s about $750 less, meaning a car advertised at that price last spring would be worth around $10,250 this spring.

Some family staples fell much further. A Nissan X-Trail in this price range was 14.3% cheaper than the same car a year earlier, about $1,400 on its typical $10,000 price last September.

A Subaru Forester in the same range fell 11.6%, about $1,200 on its typical price a year ago.

If it's a Corolla in your driveway, it fell a little less: 4.0% on the same car, about $500 on what it was listed for last September.

For your own car, knock about $6.90 off every $100 it would have been listed for a year ago. On a $15,000 used car, that’s about $1,000, so it would now be listed for around $14,000. For buyers, that’s the saving. For sellers, it’s the price they’re now competing at.

It isn't only the budget end. Across every used car on the market, the same car was listed for 6.5% less than a year earlier, so used cars are cheaper across the board.

What this means if you're buying or selling now

The buyers came back in July. Of the used cars under $20,000 listed that month, 62.5% were gone within a month, close to the pace a year earlier, and August held it at 63%. If you listed one in July at a fair price, you most likely had a buyer before the end of August.

If you’re buying, the same car is about 7% cheaper than a year ago. The useful comparison is what that same car was listed for a year ago, not what the seller paid for it. The catch is that six in ten cheap cars listed in July were gone within a month, so the one you’re weighing up this weekend may not be there the next.

If you're selling, the buyers are back but the price isn't. Six in ten cheap cars listed in July were gone within a month, and August held that pace. A car listed at last year's price is competing with ones about $750 cheaper.

Peter Willis, Carma’s Director of Buying, sees it from the trade-in side: “Buyers are active, but they have more choice at the budget end than usual. If you’re buying under $20,000, look beyond the asking price and factor in any upcoming costs like tyres, servicing or repairs. If you’re selling, be realistic about your price from the start. Buyers have enough choice to pass on a car that looks overpriced for what it is.”

Whether you're buying or selling a used car, Carma can help. Browse used cars under $20,000, each inspected and reconditioned through processes verified by the NRMA, with seven days to drive and decide. Selling instead? Get an online valuation to see what your car's worth today.